We put the new design through a remote unmoderated usability test using UserTesting.com. We recruited 12 business travellers across the US, UK, and Canada who currently use a competitor product and are planning to book a flight within the next 2 months. Participants were shown a prototype and asked to search for a flight, select seats, and check out to gather feedback.
Learning what worked: Travellers understand industry-standard language
Every single participant easily understood the new Preferred Seat, Standard Seat, and Elite Status Seat labels, accurately describing the characteristics of each one.
We asked participants to compare our seat selection process with competitor websites and received a high median satisfaction rating of 4 out of 5. Analysis of our detractors revealed that lower scores were driven entirely by technical Figma prototype constraints encountered during the test, which is thankfully a frustration I can now completely avoid in the future thanks to high-fidelity AI prototyping.
Learning what didn't work: Our new entry point was over-designed
During our usability test, we showed participants two options for the checkout layout, alternating which one they saw first to avoid bias. Option 1 utilized the existing entry point located within the flight trip details, while Option 2 placed it within a new add-ons section that had been recently implemented in a previous project.
While I felt confident in this new design because it was visually clearer and took up more real estate, I knew moving the entry point carried inherent risks since it was physically disconnected from the flight details. To my surprise, the new location was a massive detractor, with 9 out of 12 participants explicitly stating they preferred the previous design.
Guided by this feedback, we moved forward with keeping the existing entry point location. Once we confirmed it as the more valuable entry point, we quickly followed up with a targeted visual redesign of the Trip Details card itself.
